Who Should Pay for NonY2K?
Businesses that spent billions to exterminate bug want insurers to pony
Now that the hype and scattered hysteria about the threat of a Y2K computer
bug has passed as a non event, what has happened to all the lawsuits and
the windfall lawyers had expected to make as a result of computer chaos.
According to the American Bar Association Journal, Charles Kerr, a New
York City technology lawyer, says that the uneventful transition to the
new millennium "takes the wind out of the sails" of those banking
on a Y2K litigation boom. However, he still worries about the "more
insidious problem" of flawed programs that still may be operating
but collecting inaccurate data.
But the big liability boom is likely to focus on the billions of dollars
that thousands of U.S. companies spent to avert computer calamities. Already,
at least six parties -- Xerox, Unisys, GTE, Nike, the Port of Seattle
and the Royal Oak, Mich., school system -- have sued their insurers to
recover Y2K compliance costs, and policyholders nationwide have filed
These computer-age cases may turn on an insurance clause dating back to
the 17th century. Since the era of the buccaneers, maritime insurers have
required shippers to cut their losses of boats and cargo through rescue
and salvage operations. In return, the companies are reimbursed for efforts
to protect insured property -- even if they fail.
This "sue and labor" provision appears in many all-risk or property
insurance policies. Companies are beginning to assert Y2K coverage claims
under this clause, reasoning that precautions against massive computer
disasters are akin to battening down a ship for a hurricane that veered
away at the last minute.
Carriers may be paying for their own poor planning. Experts say that the
industry scrambled for approval of Y2K exclusion clauses. He says the
industry pleaded to state insurance commissioners that this new policy
language was needed because existing boilerplate did not expressly exclude
losses from software bugs. This argument may now come back to haunt insurers
trying to avoid payouts under policies without specific Y2K exclusions,
Some attorneys for the insurance companies say they are not worried that
their clients will be stuck with the tab for computer system overhauls.
They insist that Y2K readiness costs are ordinary business expenses, and
thus are not covered under conventional policies.
Some experts believe if insurance carriers lose the first few Y2K coverage
cases, there will be more litigation from "other major companies
that have spent tens of millions" preparing for the computer bug
that never bit.
Source: ABA Journal
For more E2000 stories, click here:
news | events
| Y2K | today's
news | life | party
Monday, October 23, 2017
When does the Millennium
Millennium Party Tips